Discipline makes Daring possible.

Dead ends

Dead ends

Arguably, my experience with Screwfix the other day was due to breaking this 10th principle of service design: “A Good Service should have no dead ends.”

When the local store had to close unexpectedly and temporarily, whoever was responsible for closing didn’t have authority to update the main company website.   They had reached a dead-end in the process for closing a store, which in turn led to a dead-end for me, the customer.

When you’re designing a service or process it’s a good idea to start with the most straightforward and most frequently occuring case.  But as soon as have this, you need to consider likely exceptions, and include them in your documentation.  One important exception many forget, is that your product or service is simply ‘not for’ the person trying to use it.  This is a legitimate ‘dead end’ in a way, but helping them to make an orderly and elegant exit will do no harm to your reputation.

Often, dead-ends occur when you haven’t fully considered who your users might be.   Not every shopper is 100% fit and able-bodied.  Heavy doors and steps become dead-ends for the disabled, frail or heavy-laden.  Small print makes a web-page a dead-end for someone short-sighted.  Small buttons or too-precise hand-movements create dead-ends for the arthritic or shaky-handed.  As my husband found out recently, 2-factor authentication makes online banking a dead-end for those who don’t have a mobile phone.

Of course, you’ll never be able to predict every possible exception or variation, so you need to make sure your service or process always has an ‘escape route’.  A good start is to enable a user (whether customer or team member) to talk to a human being with sufficient experience and authority to handle anything.

If you find this backstop is called on regularly or too often, you’ve discovered another common exception you didn’t allow for.

As long as you learn from the times the backstop is called for, your organisation will quickly learn to minimise the need for it.

How to really annoy your customers

How to really annoy your customers

Here’s why keeping your service consistent across channels matters.   Yesterday I drove down to our nearest Screwfix trade counter, to collect stuff we needed to start laying the floor.   I’d ordered these things online a few days earlier and chosen to collect rather than have it delivered.   I’d dutifully waited for the SMS messages that would notify me it had arrived at my chosen store and was ready to collect.  But when I turned up, the store was ‘temporarily closed’.

After navigating the labyrinth of phone messages designed to prevent you ever speaking to human being, after 10 minutes, I got through to someone, I explained my predicament.   They consulted their manager.

“That store closed a few days ago.  It should be open again soon.”

“The website said it was open.”

“If you google it, it says it says it’s temporarily closed.”

“Why on earth would I google it, when I’ve already ordered and paid for everything on the main website?  Why would I google it when I know where the store is, and I’ve received 2 separate SMS messages telling me that my order is ready for collection?”

“Oh.”

We got it sorted after a bit of nudging.  The person on the other end of the phone found me the next nearest Screwfix that had what I wanted in stock, and cancelled my order.   But a slick and easy service was totally undermined by a lack of consistency.

And, I suspect, by a failure of delegation.

 

 

Consistency

Consistency

Good Services principle number 9: A good service is consistent.

I like this principle particularly, because consistent doesn’t mean uniform.

Your services are obviously going to be different if they take place over different channels or formats, or if you have different levels of offering.   A one-to-one consultancy isn’t going to be the same as a do-it-yourself option, but your service should live up to your Promise of Value across channels, across time, across customer types and across all individual customer journeys.   There should be no gaps – something that takes extra care if your organisational structure is non-orthogonal to your processes.

The great thing about consistency is that it allows for the kind of variation that uniformity would stifle.   The kind of variation that allows you people to over-deliver on your Promise and delight individual clients – even when things go wrong.   As you design the services that enable your business to deliver though others, remember to empower that ability to vary in your team.  Not only will it make for more delight and flexibility, it will be the means by which you discover new needs and desires in your client base.

‘Consistency’ is the perfect word here because it describes how your service should feel.

That’s what keeps it human.

Tell me what’s happening

Tell me what’s happening

I’ve been ordering a lot online lately.  Not primarily because of Covid, but because we’re kitting out the extension.   I’ve had no problems at all, everyone has been well set up for online sales, and everything has worked exactly as I expected.

Until this last week.

Last Monday, I ordered some coir matting.   Ordering was more or less straightforward (once I’d understood the pricing), and I received confirmation by email, setting my expectation for when I might hear more about how my order was progressing.   So far, so good.

A few days later, I haven’t heard anything.   I call the number in the email.  It rings and rings.  “It’s late, maybe they’ve left for the day. I’ll try again tomorrow.”   The next day I call again.   It rings and rings, until finally, the call is cut off.  I try again.  Again, no answer.   “It’s Saturday, maybe lockdown has meant they can’t be there as usual.  I’ll try again on Monday.”

On Monday, I call again.  Again, no answer.  Twice.  Three times.   I send an email.  No reply – not even an automated response.

Now I’m beginning to mildly panic.   “What if they aren’t a real business?  Should I cancel the order?  How will I get my money back?  Should I be ringing my credit card company?”

I look them up on Companies House and Endole.   All seems OK.  “But what if they’ve gone bust?  Or can’t fulfill orders because of lockdown?”  

I try the head office number on the website.   A young lady answers.  “I’ll have to give you another number, we don’t handle online sales.”  It is of course, the number I’ve been calling.  I explain the situation – including my fears.  She laughs, “Of course we’re real!  But we’re not as big a company as we look online.   We’ve been really busy and it’s been a struggle to keep up.   I’ll get a message over to the warehouse and get them to call you.” 

Sure enough, an email arrives shortly afterwards – “Your order’s on the lorry, and should be with you tomorrow.  Let us know if it hasn’t arrived by Wednesday.”

And sure enough, it arrived this morning.  Phew!

There are a couple of simple things even a small business can do to prevent this kind of misunderstanding, even if you’re taken by surprise by a surge in demand:

First, immediately, have a message on the warehouse phone that lets people know they have come through to the right place.

Include in your message that if there is no answer it’s because you’re busy.   Genuinely busy.  Explain why.  If you can’t have more than 5 people in at a time, let people know.   If you’re short-staffed, let people know, and let them know what you’re doing about it.   People are very understanding if you are honest with them.

Second, as soon as you possibly can, make sure the phone gets answered by a real person.

Transfer the warehouse phone to the shop, or use a pay as you go phone answering service.  Even if they can’t track the order, they can at least take a message, answer frequently asked questions, and reassure your clients that the business is real, and their money is in safe hands.   Messages can be dealt with asynchronously, perhaps at the end of the day when the warehouse has more time.

These two simple, cheap and relatively easy actions will also reduce the number of incoming calls (e.g. my 7 calls would go down to 1), removing the incentive for harried warehouse people to ignore the phone.

The ultimate aim is of course, to make the communication of what’s happening with my order a side-effect of the fulfillment, but don’t wait until that’s in place – if you don’t tell me, your remote client, the real story, I’ll make up my own, and it might be wild.

Online, communicating what’s happening to an order is as important is actually fulfilling it.

See what I mean?

See what I mean?

As it happens, I didn’t have to wait long for a lovely illustration for yesterday’s principle: “a good service works in a way that’s familiar..

Last night, we made the final decision on the flooring for our new extension.   A metre of coconut matting in front of the big outside doors, with the bamboo flooring starting after that and flowing through to the library.

I went online to shop around for the matting.  It came in 2 widths, lots of colours (black of course!) and could be cut to size.   Everywhere I looked it seemed to be around the same reasonable price of £18 – £20, yet every time I entered my desired dimensions, the price jumped to anywhere between £125 to £450.  What was going on?   I couldn’t work it out.  So I asked a chat line.

This morning the answer came “The price is £18 for 0.25 metres – how much do you need?”.

Doh!

I was expecting to buy this flooring the way I buy every other kind of flooring – by the square metre.

I can sort of see where this convention came from (many people only need .25 or .5 of a metre for a doormat), and why with online shopping, every seller adopted it.

But I bet nobody has thought through what effect it has on sales.   First, it feels like you are doing something wrong, then it feels a little bit like a rip-off, because the price you see is nowhere near the price you actually pay.  I nearly gave up on the idea altogether.

The answer is simple.   Make it work like everything else, then let me know how it’s different.  In this case, that I can buy less than a metre if I need to.

Set Expectations

Set Expectations

How many times have you run out of page writing a notice?   Or got halfway through a recipe before realising you were missing a vital ingredient?   Or partway through a task before realising that you simply don’t have time to complete it?

When you build a business that works through others you have to find a way of enabling them to work autonomously and responsibly.  I believe the best way to achieve that is to help people to manage themselves.

In this mini-series, I’m exploring how you can use some of the principles of Service Design to help you do that, using the principles outlined in this brilliant book by Lou Downe “Good Services” as my starting point.  Let me stress, this is not a re-hash of the book, but an exploration of how it fits with my ideas for turning a business into a system for makeing and keeping promises.   The book is well worth buying for yourself!

A service helps a user to do something.   You want your team to share and deliver your promise on your behalf.   So treat them as your users and build them services that help them to do that.

The third principle Lou gives is that ‘a service sets the expectations of the user’.

Setting expectations is about making sure that kind of thing doesn’t happen.   That’s why easy-to-follow recipes start with the oven temperature, prep time and cooking time, then the list of ingredients.   So you can be prepared before you start cooking.

It’s possible to do the same for services, whether they are for your clients or your team to use:

  • Give people an idea of how long it will take – it could even be a range: “30 minutes the first time you do it, 15 minutes once you’re experienced“.  Setting a time expectation doesn’t just help people prepare, it also helps them spot an exception when it’s happening: “If it takes longer than 10 minutes something isn’t right.”
  • Tell them what props they need to assemble before they start.  Include everything they will need, both physical and electronic.   This is an especially good idea where the activity involves assembling a collection before traveling off to deliver the service somewhere else.   A checklist really helps.   You can use the same list to assemble them again after completion.   Even surgeons ‘count out’ swabs, forceps and other bits and pieces.

If you build this into the definition of your service, you’ll save false starts, repeated steps and interruptions, and help everyone feel more in control.

Easy to find

Easy to find

When you build a business that works through others you have to find a way of enabling them to work autonomously and responsibly.

The traditional way of doing that was to build a hierarchy of management above those doing the work, to supervise, check  and adjust how things get done.   The problem with that approach is that it’s unresponsive, expensive and actually makes it harder for people to work autonomously and responsibly.  And if you are a small business owner trying to do all of that yourself, it can nearly kill you and the business.

The alternative is to help people to manage themselves.    For that, they need a framework that supports them, but doesn’t stifle their ability to respond creatively and humanely to emergent scenarios.   There are lots of familiar models and analogies for this kind of framework – a map, a blueprint, a screenplay, for example.   My preferred analogy is a musical score – what I call your Customer Experience Score – that describes what has to happen and when to deliver the experience you want your clients to have when they deal with you – but leaves the how to the talented musicians you employ.

But how do you create that score?

In this mini-series, I’m exploring how you can use some of the principles of Service Design to help you create a Customer Experience Score that works well, using the principles outlined in this brilliant book by Lou Downe “Good Services” as my starting point.  Let me stress, this is not a re-hash of the book, but an exploration of how it fits with my ideas for turning a business into a system for makeing and keeping promises.   The book is well worth buying for yourself!

The basic idea is simple.   A service helps a user to do something.   You want your team to share and deliver your promise on your behalf.   So treat them as your users and build them services that help them to do that.

The first principle is that ‘a service should be easy to find’ – even when you don’t know what it is.

Imagine you’re a newbie to your business.   How do you find out what you’re supposed to do in your job?   Where do you look?  What do you look for?  As a newbie, on probation, eager to impress, you want to be productive from day one.   All too often that means asking someone who is already busy.

So the first thing that might help make services easy to find is to put them all in one place.   You could call it an operations manual, but nowadays it’s more likely to be online, and searchable in more varied ways than a physical folder or file.  What’s key is that:

  • everyone knows where to look for it
  • there is only one place to look for it
  • there is only one version of it (apart from backups)
  • it is kept up to date
  • people can find what they need in it

How can you help your team find the service they need?

The name is a good place to start.   Ask yourself:  What do clients usually call this service?  What do we normally call it?   What do experts call it?   Are those names the same?   If not, what are your options?

A service should primarily be known by one name.    Preferably one taken from the client’s perspective.   This helps to remind everyone why this service exists – to help the client get the outcome they want – especially if it’s really part of a larger service for the client.   You might call it ‘VAT reporting’, but the real service to the client might be ‘Meet Statutory Obligations’.  You might call it ‘Management Accounting’, but the real service to the client is ‘Control My Business’.

This highlights another important aspect of naming.   A service is an activity that helps someone do something.  So it’s a good idea to name the activity to reflect what gets done when it works.   This name is usually made up of two parts – a verb that describes what happens, followed by a noun that describes the thing it happens to e.g. ‘Draft VAT Return’.

This works at all levels of granularity, from the lowest level – ‘Draft VAT Return’, ‘Approve VAT Return’ or ‘File VAT Return’, up to ‘Report VAT’, ‘Meet Statutory Obligations’ and finally ‘Keep Promise’.   The name should tell you exactly where you get to after you’ve completed the activity successfully.   You’re there or you’re not, and if you’re not, you haven’t actually completed the activity.

By naming a service or activity in this way, you’ve also met the second principle, which is that ‘a service should clearly explain its purpose’.

Once you’ve arrived at this kind of name, you can make sure it’s findable by any of the other names you identified at the beginning.

With a clearly explained purpose and a customer-focused name, findable by familiar alternatives, you’ll help you newbies get up to productive speed much faster – by themselves.   Which should make both of you much happier.

Spell it out

Spell it out

I chuckled to myself as I approached the till, after waiting in line for a while.

I’m laughing at myself” I explained to the woman sat behind it, “because you can’t see me smiling at you.

I’d forgotten that I was, of course, wearing a face covering.

No.” she replied.

Well I am smiling at you.

She laughed back at me.

Sometimes, it really helps to spell it out.

 

Watching other people work

Watching other people work

I must confess to having a bit of a thing about phone answering services.   Not because I dislike them, but because I think they are one of those things that can really enhance the customer experience when done well.

You can always tell when someone is using an answering service, because you get asked more questions that you often would, and you can tell there’s a process going on.  That’s a good thing, something more businesses that answer their own phones should learn to do.   It would save a lot of miscommunication.

When someone providing this service does it really well, I have a genuine conversation.   I am allowed to ramble a little about why I’m calling (the person I want to speak to knows I’m due to call and why), but they still get from me (not necessarily by asking me) the information they need to pass on the message – my name (including how to spell it), my business name, why I’m calling and who I want to speak to, and finally how they can get hold of me.

I can even have a separate conversation about the fact that they provide the service, which is how I found out who they were.

Its a pleasure to participate in someone doing their job with commitment intelligence and humanity.   Its an enjoyable experience for me as customer, prospect or supplier as well as for the person doing it.

That’s why your Customer Experience ScoreTM needs to cover everything.

 

PS the company was Take My Calls.   When my current credit runs out, I’ll be switching to them.

Related

Related

This was last weekend’s reading.

Strangely enough, they are related.  I recommend reading them together.